Apparently,
there is a distinction between ratification of the Hague convention (on the
protection of children and cooperation in respect of inter-country adoption)
and becoming a signatory to the convention. Signing means that South Korea
officially declared that it agrees in principle with the requirements of the
Hague, and that it intends to become a party to the convention. In order to ratify,
South Korea will need to modernize its policy, legislative and organizational
frameworks such that these will be in compliance with the Hague. With
ratification, South Korea will have the legal obligation to apply the
convention.
From my understanding, South Korea signed the Hague convention on May 24, 2013, but this does not mean that South Korea must take further action to ratify the convention. The South Korean ministry responsible for ratifying the Hague has not yet set a date for bringing the Hague requirements into force.
Does this mean that until new policies and legislation are established or old ones are amended to be compliant with the Hague, South Korea does not have to enforce the Hague? Is it possible that South Korea, to show good faith and agreement in principle with the Hague, will change some of its policies or processes and enforce some requirements in the interim?
It can take a really long time to create or amend legislation that affects multiple organizational structures and systems, such as setting standards for training, certification, monitoring and compliance. To illustrate how long things can take, let's take a look at the experiences of a few countries. In 1994, the US signed the convention and it wasn't until 2007 when it was ratified. It came into force in 2008.
On December 7, 2010, Vietnam signed the convention, and this was ratified on November 1, 2011. The convention was entered into force in Vietnam on February 1, 2012. Even with ratification, the US still cautions its prospective adoptive parents and agencies that still more important steps need to be taken by Vietnam before the US will permit inter-country adoptions again from Vietnam. In Cambodia's case, it ratified the convention in 2007 but has not managed to reform its child protection system deemed satisfactory to the international community. Like the US, the UK has objected to Cambodia's accession to the Hague and so adoptions from Cambodia would not be recognised in the UK as Hague convention adoptions.
Our agency, like us, received news of South Korea's signing of the Hague through news alerts. Our agency has not received word of potential implications on waiting families from its counterpart in South Korea. Given the trends of impacts on countries after joining the Hague, there is a lot of speculation, frustration and fear. Our agency is being wise to wait until they receive official and accurate information.
I was reassured that we'll get matched. We're the fifth official family in waiting among six so far this year. The uncertainty about when we'll get matched is increasing. There will definitely be a delay. How long? Our agency is not sure; it could be several months or more. Until the delay ends, we won't know exactly by how much - right now, everything is a speculation.
From my understanding, South Korea signed the Hague convention on May 24, 2013, but this does not mean that South Korea must take further action to ratify the convention. The South Korean ministry responsible for ratifying the Hague has not yet set a date for bringing the Hague requirements into force.
Does this mean that until new policies and legislation are established or old ones are amended to be compliant with the Hague, South Korea does not have to enforce the Hague? Is it possible that South Korea, to show good faith and agreement in principle with the Hague, will change some of its policies or processes and enforce some requirements in the interim?
It can take a really long time to create or amend legislation that affects multiple organizational structures and systems, such as setting standards for training, certification, monitoring and compliance. To illustrate how long things can take, let's take a look at the experiences of a few countries. In 1994, the US signed the convention and it wasn't until 2007 when it was ratified. It came into force in 2008.
On December 7, 2010, Vietnam signed the convention, and this was ratified on November 1, 2011. The convention was entered into force in Vietnam on February 1, 2012. Even with ratification, the US still cautions its prospective adoptive parents and agencies that still more important steps need to be taken by Vietnam before the US will permit inter-country adoptions again from Vietnam. In Cambodia's case, it ratified the convention in 2007 but has not managed to reform its child protection system deemed satisfactory to the international community. Like the US, the UK has objected to Cambodia's accession to the Hague and so adoptions from Cambodia would not be recognised in the UK as Hague convention adoptions.
Our agency, like us, received news of South Korea's signing of the Hague through news alerts. Our agency has not received word of potential implications on waiting families from its counterpart in South Korea. Given the trends of impacts on countries after joining the Hague, there is a lot of speculation, frustration and fear. Our agency is being wise to wait until they receive official and accurate information.
I was reassured that we'll get matched. We're the fifth official family in waiting among six so far this year. The uncertainty about when we'll get matched is increasing. There will definitely be a delay. How long? Our agency is not sure; it could be several months or more. Until the delay ends, we won't know exactly by how much - right now, everything is a speculation.
No comments:
Post a Comment