Showing posts with label China. Show all posts
Showing posts with label China. Show all posts

Thursday, 4 July 2013

What Happens After the Ratification of the Hague?

There's a story I share when I'm asked why there are fewer and fewer children up for adoption from China and elsewhere in the world. People are shocked when they hear that the wait to adopt from China was getting increasingly longer and longer and once it became longer than 7 years, it became potentially unethical for agencies to accept new applications and their adoption programs were eventually closed. The story I share is that China has become quite developed in many cities and its population now has the resources to adopt domestically and so there are fewer abandoned children. Also, I've said that girls are now more favoured in their societies, likely from positive government promotion and the availability of jobs in cities for women. Through employment, women have become empowered and have sent money home for their families. Surely, given the size of China, the size of its middle-income earners must surpass the population of Canada. Think of all of that buying power, empowered women and the potential ability to adopt domestically.

Then I saw a CTVnews article on China banning the private adoptions of abandoned children. According to the article, China implemented the ban to prevent people who find an abandoned child from taking that child home, all under the radar of the authorities. Instead, the authorities require that when infants are found abandoned, local residential committees and the police must be informed immediately and infants must not be adopted informally. Each year in China, about 200,000 infants are abandoned - astounding! And girl infants are the ones who are mostly found among the abandoned.

Parents and parents-to- be are so restricted by the one-child policy, the lack of social security in old age, and the pervasive culture of favoured boys over girls, that many pursue another child in the hopes they give birth to a baby boy. The unintended consequences of these policy decisions affect both urban and rural families. In cities, only one child is permitted. In farming communities, a second child is only allowed if their first child is a girl. All this is to say that girls are far more likely to be abandoned. Also likely to be abandoned are infants and children with special needs. Other cultural factors also come into play such as the stigma of being a single mother which is prevalent in many Asian countries.

China has ratified the Hague convention on inter-country adoption and cooperation, which should serve to ensure a strong child welfare system, loving families and homes for orphans, and of course, the trafficking of infants is forbidden. But the keeping of abandoned babies in China was perfectly legal, up until now. Recently, China's Ministry of Civil Affairs posted on its website the new rules that prevent the domestic unlawful adoption of abandoned babies. The rules certainly do allow domestic adoption but under regulation, which specify that the adoptive parents must be over 30 years of age, be childless and be healthy, as well as meet other requirements. These checks and balances include the requirement that the police undertake a search to locate the parents or guardians of the abandoned babies, and babies must be placed in a certified home for temporary care if parents or guardians are not found within a period of time. Care in these homes can become longer term when parents or guardians are not found, but only under official authority.

The reality is that international adoption of relatively healthy children from China has been closed for some years now. And, I think the question is where have abandoned infants been placed each year? Have there been enough concerned citizens, stepping in but with few supports, taking in these children in past years? And now with oversight and awareness of domestic unlawful adoption, will there be more children that need the services of state orphanages – but can they take in more children going forward?

What I learned and what seems logical is that state orphanages in China are busting at the seams in terms of their ability to take care of abandoned children. How can children's developmental needs also be met when they are growing up in institutions that are not fully supported?

One would presume that the incentive for child trafficking would decrease when there are fewer and fewer options to supply children for international adoption (i.e., directly limiting the number of children available for international adoption) - but has the number of children needing homes been reduced? Has there been more domestic adoption? The CTVnews article seems to suggest that children continue to be abandoned in regular numbers and orphanages are beyond full capacity. In scenarios like these, was the ratification of the Hague convention the better option?