Wednesday, 19 June 2013

Fatherhood Through Crowdsourcing


Last Sunday was Father's Day - a day that reminds all dads and dads in waiting that life without kids is a life not fully lived. And for kids, a day that reminds us of the tremendous love we received from our dads, so much so that we want to share that love with our kids or kids to be. I was struck also by the significance of this Day for those who want to be dads but are facing infertility challenges. I wish to dedicate this post to those want-to-be dads who are experiencing 50% of all infertility cases.

Men these days face similar masculinity pressures, as in the past, when their ability to conceive is challenged. The stigma prevents many men from stepping up and getting the help they need. There is increasing evidence that waiting too long could result in reduced sperm quality and a slight increase in negative health outcomes of the children born from men older than 40 years.

We've come a long way. Our assisted human reproduction technologies are most effective in treating male factor infertility, resolving almost 99% of all cases. With such a high rate of success, there is no reason for men to wait or suffer in silence. Waiting too long to seek help could mean that the woman partner would have increasing age and decreasing fertility, and this could result in much lower chances of pregnancy for the couple.

Although in vitro fertilization and intracytoplasmic sperm injection or ICSI can bypass male factor infertility issues, other issues can present barriers, such as the cost for one treatment cycle, around $10,000, and the availability or access to fertility clinics. And there is the emotional, psychological, physical and time costs to these treatments.

One ingenious IT specialist in Vancouver knew that he had to take action sooner rather than later given both him and his wife were 32 years old and his continually dropping sperm count. His dropping sperm count was the result of a tumour that was pressing on his pituitary gland, and the medication to curb this drop was not doing its job. With the financial barrier being too great, he crowdsourced funds online, sometimes known as crowdfunding, for his IVF treatments and was successful in getting enough donations to cover the cost of the first treatment. Support came in from friends, family, and complete strangers who just wanted to help.

Crowdfunding is capturing international and national attention; however, as a concept it is not new.

Crowdfunding offers new hope for those experiencing financial barriers to creating their nuclear family. They can create an online campaign through established platforms, like GoFundMe, and present a compelling story. And through this, the miracles of assisted human reproduction or adoption could bring their forever child into their lives, and together they would each achieve their dreams of a forever family.

Sunday, 16 June 2013

My Journey Begins – Creating My Family

When I stood there, looking into his eyes and he looking into mine, I knew this was a moment that I was not going to forget. We held hands; mine were trembling and his felt strong. It was such a personal affair, and yet here we were - standing in front of so many people. They were witnessing our forever commitment to each other. This kind of ceremony probably has been happening since man walked the earth. I was so happy to be standing there, seeing my present and my future before me, feeling secure, excited and ready to start my next journey. My best friend became my husband that day. The tears welling in my eyes were a reflection of my joy and awe at the significance of that moment – one of the happiest moments in my life.

Our wedding day was eight years ago – and we made plans to have children before we got married, knowing fully there was a chance we may not be able to - the natural way.

We were open to all options of family creation that were available to us. When the natural way didn’t work, I went through a series of myomectomies – the first one was almost within the year after our marriage.

I was diagnosed with fibroids early in my adult life - in my mid-twenties. And they were growing fast! The year before my first myomectomy, they had grown so much that the size of my uterus was described as fourth months of pregnancy by my doctor. The pain of a heavy uterus but no baby! How wonderful in my first year of marriage? My kind, patient, and “we’ll deal with whatever is before us-husband” was just so wonderful through all of this – yes, I did find an awesome catch.

What an ordeal I went through – appointments after appointments – for three years! I was working overtime and feeling the pressures of having to deliver on high priority and urgent files during those years. It was hard trying to squeeze time for appointments – I ended up working really long days to make up the time I took off. With 80 days of banked sick leave credits up to that point, I should have been more kind to myself. Being kind to myself is something that I re-learn every day!

Three years of doing whatever I could to help normalize my uterus and its lining – it made me numb at times – going through the process, hoping for the best, and ending up with scars and dark skin discolouration from the high estrogen doses. I had to have three to four follow-up visits after each myomectomy, initially to remove the foley catheter balloon from the uterine cavity, and then to undergo a series of intrauterine “scrapings” to remove scar tissue. The balloon and these scrapings were meant to prevent the formation of intrauterine adhesions.

Soon after these surgeries, we started exploring international adoption as well as domestic public adoption. We got off to a rocky start when exploring our first international program, and decided to take a year off from this. During this time, we pursued the domestic public route. We eventually realized that this route was not a match for us. Then we tried international surrogacy, and that also didn’t work. We even explored domestic private adoption, contacted both facilitators licensed in our city, and left our profile with them. During that time, we were permitted to straddle domestic and international adoption programs, as long as we were not straddling more than one international program. Given the rate of domestic private adoptions, we were not expecting much - but we wanted to make sure that we explored all options available to us.

We decided to revisit the same international program and commit to it - we completed our homestudy, compiled all of our paperwork and submitted them in the fall of 2010. Then, we discovered that this program essentially froze right after our dossier was logged-in in the sending country. After two years of waiting and seeing only minimal movement (i.e., only a few healthy child adoptions and the rest are special needs adoption; all well under the annual quota), we decided to switch to another international program that was showing promise.

Here we are now, waiting again. But we are hopeful this time, based on a recent reassurance we received from our agency – that although South Korea signed the Hague convention on May 24, 2013, there were two child referrals in early June from dossiers that were sent in March 2013! Most of the time, I’m hopeful – I want to be. And sometimes, I wonder if I should be worried – because the Social Welfare Society received our dossier in South Korea after the signing.

Thursday, 13 June 2013

Single Embryo Transfers

It’s been decades and still infertility specialists and bioethicists can’t seem to agree on the numbers of embryos to transfer as part of an in vitro-fertilization procedure (IVF).  The point of contention happens when a woman is 40 or older.  

Recently, the infertility community in Canada agreed on a guideline to assist doctors in transferring the right number of embryos into a woman after IVF. There is consensus for women under 40, and particularly for women under 35 who have higher rates of success and the chances of multiple births are higher when two or more embryos are transferred. The new guidelines require that only one embryo is transferred in when a woman is under 35. Between the ages of 35 and 39, up to two embryos can be transferred when there is documented history that multiples are unlikely to occur for a particular patient having a poor prognosis.

The risks of multiple births are real and the guidelines aim to curb these. But these are just guidelines - and there are professional standards that doctors adhere to in the delivery of medical services – these standards allow doctors to exercise their best judgement depending on the prognosis of each individual patient. In the absence of federal or provincial regulation regarding the total number of embryos to transfer, these standards that are tied to the licensing of physicians can bear some weight.

Between the ages of 35 and 39, the IVF success rate hovers around 26.5% and for women under 35, the success rate is 37.4% - but for women 40 and over, the rate is just under 12% and this is with multiple embryos being transferred. In Canada, the risk of multiples is 21% among all IVF procedures. To put this into context, there are 31 fertility clinics in Canada, and among these, 29 reported a total of 1,287 multiple pregnancies, including 1,217 twins, 65 triplets and five quads in 2011. 

The new guidelines allow doctors to transfer up to four or five embryos in women 40 and over, recognizing that women in this age range have very low IVF success rates. But this number is the maximum – and the number that would get transferred depends on the doctors’ best judgement. The prognosis of each woman over 40 can be quite different. These guidelines permit three or four embryos to be transferred into women between the ages of 40 and 42. 

Up to five are permitted when a woman is older than 42, but this number would depend on the number of days after fertilization when the embryos are transferred and the prognosis of the woman. The quality of embryos from a woman over 40 is so poor that doctors transfer back more than two in the hopes that at least one embryo will implant. And, the longer their embryos are kept in vitro after fertilization, the more clearly their quality becomes apparent – and the more information doctors have about how many can be transferred.

Recognizing that the occurrence of multiples is increased through the practice of IVF - and the heavy burden on the healthcare system due to premature births from multiple embryo transfers - there is a constant push and pull towards making the system of fertility treatment more healthy for the women involved and the families that are created. Creating a higher number of embryos per cycle is potentially risky for the women receiving the stimulating drugs, and the act of transferring more than two embryos could result in high risk pregnancies and unintended special needs that children may face. 

Quebec is the only province in Canada where the public medical care system pays for up to six cycles of single embryo transfers for each woman. And governments paying for IVF cycles could reduce the incentive to transfer more than one embryo per cycle. For other provinces to consider this, I think, the benefit-cost ratio of single embry transfer has to outweigh other forms of family creation.

In addition to assisted human reproduction, there are other ways to create one's family – approaches that can be less costly to the healthcare system. But, the selection of one over another is never an easy choice and it is possible – over time – that many approaches are revisited.

Saturday, 8 June 2013

Balance in Chaos - Finding Peace

Life is too complex. The experience of one person is too hard to generalize and capture in one word, one measure. The outcome of each person is hard to predict. The possible paths that one can take in life are numerous. Until the outcome arrives, life can continue to be a mystery. I think this explains how surprised we are when we hear that an acquaintance, friend, or relative chose to quit their very secure and well-paying job in their forties or fifties to co-find a start-up - for example, on the other side of the world.

The things that draw us, repel us, mellow us, make us happy, make us sad, are all intermingling, and out of this pot, there is a mystery to be discovered. And this mystery is even more possible, I think because we live in such a land of opportunity, where we have the options and choices to create, reinvent, and transform ourselves. These options include the various ways we can choose to build our families.

Many families these days are blended; for example, from the joining of two single-parent households or through adoption. Other families are created through assisted human reproduction, while others result through strong bonds of friendships and commitment to each other. Creating a family through adoption also means facing many other choices, such as domestic public adoption, domestic private adoption, and international adoption. The latter is also wrought with choices. This is all to say that sometimes the doors are not closed to us - sometimes, we still can have a family of our own, have more than one child, and even, we might have grandchildren - because there are possibilities out there for us.

We all have a right to build our family - and sometimes we are prevented from fully realizing the options out there - because sometimes we are so committed to following through on one approach. Because by nature, we are fearlessly loyal to the path we chose, to remain head strong and protect our investments, whether relational, emotional, psychological, financial, or physical. Sometimes, it is the very people we look to that hold us back from exploring other options - not from any fault of their own but their unending support for us, their desire to keep our spirits high, their hope that through positive thinking, our physical bodies and the external, emotional, and physical world will coalesce and find perfect equilibrium. Sometimes, it is just an issue of being at the right place, at the right time, with the right people - life can just be that serendipitous.

I do want to emphasize that where we do have choices, these are ours to make, in the end. And that it is difficult to make these choices, to find the right mix for you and your partner, or just yourself - in your current situation - to find the balance that can remain as time passes. Sometimes, the choice is clear as mud, sometimes it is not.

If you are finding it difficult to convince yourself that living a child-free life is satisfying or that you don't deserve to have more than one child when your friend, family or co-worker, for example, can't have even one of their own, then it may be time to re-explore your choices. You may not have found your balance. Sometimes it is not too late to create your family, and sometimes life still has that much mystery to give you so that you can still find your balance - that balance that will put you at peace.

Friday, 7 June 2013

Progress in South Korean Adoptions - Soon After Signing the Hague Convention

We received good news recently from our agency about new referrals last week and this week - this is promising for us as the families had their dossiers sent to South Korea in March! Two months to get a referral is astounding given that the new adoption law was enacted last August and South Korea just signed the Hague convention. Then my practical side kicked in - these dossiers were sent before the signing of the Hague - maybe these aren't as affected as those that were or will be sent afterwards. 

Our adoption dossier arrived in South Korea the week after it became a signatory - literally just days after. The signing occurred on May 24, 2013, and our dossier arrived on May 27, 2013, or the day after.  It wasn't until earlier this week when our agency was notified that our dossiers were received.  

Our agency was informed that South Korea plans to continue to match families with children.  At present, the view is that there isn't any indication from the Social Welfare Society of any significant changes, as our agency was asked to continue to send dossiers to the Social Welfare Society.  Also good news, eight month old boys were referred to our families -  yeah!  I'm so happy for these families and I can't wait for them to meet their forever baby boys!  I hope it comes sooner, rather than later.

Another family from our agency received a referral last July, just before the new law came into force. They just completed their court appearance in South Korea to finalize their adoption order. Their presence is a requirement under the new law to show how serious they are about adopting their child.

Previously, the adoption order was finalized in our provincial court, and this only required one travel period to South Korea to pick up our forever child once the child's visa was issued. Under the new law, two travel periods may be needed:  one to finalize the adoption order; and another to bring our child home.  There is the possibility of remaining in South Korea for the entire time, but this could stretch to over a month while waiting to receive the child's visa. I think for many waiting families, approval for a month of absence from work may be challenging, particularly for both moms and dads.

Our July family was stuck in the confusion between the new and old law - and unfortunately, had to wait until early this year for processes and new operating standards to get sorted out and for things to get moving again in South Korea. That is why, I think, our families are apprehensive about yet again, upcoming policy changes that would result from the signing of the Hague convention.

The experience of our July family is being used as an indication of how things will play out under the new law. This is so unfortunate that they have to go through this, urghh! They are now in the 14-day waiting period after the court appearance and before the adoption order can be finalized and issued.  Upon issuance of the adoption order, the Social Welfare Society will request the issuance of the visa for the child - this will be a tremendous milestone - the clearance for their forever child to come home with them to Canada!!!

The one month waiting period reflects the time required to receive the child's visa.  And our July family is apparently the first case that the Social Welfare Society has since the new law. Their experience will be used to estimate the timelines.

Our hope is that timeframes will shorten once processes have been established. Both the father and mother were required to be present for the court appearance and at least one parent is required to travel to Canada with their forever child.

In our July family's case, the father chose to return to Canada after the court appearance and the mother stayed on and will bring their child home. I guess that this, for now, is the only way to avoid making two trips. I wonder how this mom will manage her month-long wait in Seoul - I hope that she gets to see her son as much as possible while she's there!

Wednesday, 5 June 2013

South Korean Adoption Requirements


South Korea has a long history in international adoption, unlike many of the commonly known countries, like China and Vietnam.  Korea started cooperation in international adoption since the 1950’s on a quota basis that can change each year.  This quota is set for each agency accredited to facilitate adoptions from South Korea, and so a limited number of children are placed with our agency. When I started earlier in the year, the quota was set at 21. This was good news – it was two higher than the previous year.

Age , weight, health and income are areas of considerations when adopting from South Korea. Luckily for us, we are within the acceptable thresholds. But, it’s sad that many others may be kept from realizing a family of their own due to these criteria. It is always best to double check with an adoption agency facilitating adoptions from South Korea on these thresholds. There may be different requirements depending on the country you’re from. From my understanding, at the time my child and I are united, I can’t be older than 44 years of age and younger than 26 years of age. There is some concern if an applicant is between 42 and 44 years of age, depending on the pace of adoptions from South Korea. For example, although we can’t know until things unfold, with South Korea signing the Hague convention, the quota for our agency may decrease while the availability of children with mild correctable special needs increases. In this scenario, if I was 43 years of age and was looking to adopt a child with no special needs, I may be suggested to pursue another country for international adoption. I would likely be older than 44 years by the time we’re matched with our forever child.

There should be more flexibility with weight considerations. Weight is something we can lose. The weight threshold is a body mass index (BMI) of 30 or less. Your BMI is a number based on your weight and height that helps to show whether you’re at a healthy weight for your height. If that number increases, it may mean that you’re gaining more body fat. With a high BMI, you could be at risk of chronic health conditions, such as heart disease and diabetes, and your health professionals could screen you into general support programs to help you reduce your weight.  To give you an idea, the following are BMI ranges for different weight groupings for adults older than 19 years old: 
  • BMI of less than 18.5 is interpreted as being underweight
  • BMI between 18.5 and 24.9 is interpreted as being of normal weight
  • BMI between 25 and 29.9 is interpreted as being overweight
  • BMI of 30 or more is interpreted as being obese
It goes without saying that a healthy weight is usually associated with good health, but the Korean requirements don’t stop there.  To qualify, applicants are not allowed to have any current medical conditions, and a long list is provided of those that must be ruled out. These include a history of serious medical conditions, chronic illnesses, infectious or degenerative diseases, seizure disorder, or severe physical disabilities or deformities. A history of diagnosis and treatment of mental health illnesses or problems are also ruled out, and applicants must not have received any related counselling. This list took my breath away the first time I saw it. It seemed extensive. But after discussing the requirements with my agency, I became more reassured. The list, it was explained to me, was targeting the serious conditions that would impair one’s ability to appropriately care for an adopted child.

There is some flexibility in the consideration of medical issues that are treatable – exceptions could be made for these issues on a case-by-case basis. For other health conditions that don’t require treatment, exceptions could also be made.  These conditions include migraines, allergies, hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism, asthma, and benign heart conditions. When I first saw allergies among the list, I had a moment of doubt – both of us have mild allergies that we treat with over the counter medications when the season changes. Again, it’s important to double check these restrictions with your agency. I think often times, these restrictions are guidelines and only those working in the field know how seriously they would be applied. My agency reassured me that my hubby and I are fine – good to go.
    
When it comes to income, I was surprised that the threshold required was quite flexible. Over $50,000 gross annually is the combined minimum family income required to be able to adopt from South Korea. I think that this threshold recognizes the transfers that low-income families receive from both the provincial and federal government. These transfers can supplement family incomes and provide the means to ensure healthy psycho-social development of children.  Additional income will help pay for their enrolment in extra-curricular activities and remedial help from tutors.  These supplements could bring about $5,000.00 per year into the pockets of low-income families, but this value decreases with increasing family income up to about $80,000.00. And when a family already has children in the home, the minimum combined family income may be reconsidered and a higher amount may be required.
 
There is a minimum requirement of three years of wedlock. South Korea does not accept single applicants, more than one divorce per partner, or applications from same sex couples. The family home cannot have more than four children and if there are other adopted children in the home, only one child is permitted to be adopted from a country other than South Korea.

All in all, it is important to always check in with your agency or the agency that would be facilitating your adoption. These requirements can change, especially with changes in policies in South Korea, such as what we’ll see in the near future as South Korea reassesses its current child protection system and brings this system into more alignment with the Hague requirements.

The criteria noted above are among a longer list of requirements that touch on areas related to one’s character. Again, please check the guidelines in your country, see what the thresholds are there, and check in with your agency – it is an amazing resource to help decipher what these requirements mean.

Saturday, 1 June 2013

Ratification of the Hague Convention - Not Yet in South Korea


Apparently, there is a distinction between ratification of the Hague convention (on the protection of children and cooperation in respect of inter-country adoption) and becoming a signatory to the convention. Signing means that South Korea officially declared that it agrees in principle with the requirements of the Hague, and that it intends to become a party to the convention. In order to ratify, South Korea will need to modernize its policy, legislative and organizational frameworks such that these will be in compliance with the Hague. With ratification, South Korea will have the legal obligation to apply the convention.

From my understanding, South Korea signed the Hague convention on May 24, 2013, but this does not mean that South Korea must take further action to ratify the convention. The South Korean ministry responsible for ratifying the Hague has not yet set a date for bringing the Hague requirements into force.

Does this mean that until new policies and legislation are established or old ones are amended to be compliant with the Hague, South Korea does not have to enforce the Hague? Is it possible that South Korea, to show good faith and agreement in principle with the Hague, will change some of its policies or processes and enforce some requirements in the interim?

It can take a really long time to create or amend legislation that affects multiple organizational structures and systems, such as setting standards for training, certification, monitoring and compliance. To illustrate how long things can take, let's take a look at the experiences of a few countries. In 1994, the US signed the convention and it wasn't until 2007 when it was ratified. It came into force in 2008.

On December 7, 2010, Vietnam signed the convention, and this was ratified on November 1, 2011. The convention was entered into force in Vietnam on February 1, 2012. Even with ratification, the US still cautions its prospective adoptive parents and agencies that still more important steps need to be taken by Vietnam before the US will permit inter-country adoptions again from Vietnam. In Cambodia's case, it ratified the convention in 2007 but has not managed to reform its child protection system deemed satisfactory to the international community. Like the US, the UK has objected to Cambodia's accession to the Hague and so adoptions from Cambodia would not be recognised in the UK as Hague convention adoptions.

Our agency, like us, received news of South Korea's signing of the Hague through news alerts. Our agency has not received word of potential implications on waiting families from its counterpart in South Korea. Given the trends of impacts on countries after joining the Hague, there is a lot of speculation, frustration and fear. Our agency is being wise to wait until they receive official and accurate information.

I was reassured that we'll get matched. We're the fifth official family in waiting among six so far this year. The uncertainty about when we'll get matched is increasing. There will definitely be a delay. How long? Our agency is not sure; it could be several months or more. Until the delay ends, we won't know exactly by how much - right now, everything is a speculation.