Saturday, 25 May 2013

Getting Canadian Citizenship for Children Born Abroad Through Surrogacy

Just like me, you might be thinking about how a child conceived through surrogacy abroad might be brought back to Canada. I certainly had these thoughts running through my mind when I was in the midst of my surrogacy attempt. At the time, it seemed like there were no answers in sight. It was years later when I discovered that Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) produced an operational bulletin to provide directions to people who were successful with surrogacy abroad - unlike me.

This operational bulletin was produced to help Canadian parents obtain citizenship for their child born abroad where there is no genetic link between the child and either of the parents. I guess there have been cases of surrogacy abroad in which there were no genetic link. Without genetic lineage, the child is not eligible for Canadian citizenship by descent. 

As I'm not a lawyer, I'm going to explain this in my own terms - a person is determined to be a parent based on intention, not just through a genetic link. Without a link, that person would need to show evidence of intention to parent and show evidence of a legal parent/child relationship, according to the law. 

Where there is no doubt, determination of parentage is determined based on a birth certificate. But, when there is doubt, DNA will be requested.

If DNA results show that there is no genetic lineage, there are two scenarios that intending parents may need to address depending on their situation. In the first, if the intending parents are not yet legal parents in the foreign country, they can proceed through intercountry adoption to legalize the parental relationship. Through this process, the intending parents can apply for Canadian citizenship or immigration.

In the second scenario, the intending parents are recognized as legal parents in the foreign jurisdiction, and their name(s) are on the birth certificate. In this case, adoption may not be done. Parents in these situations must send in confirmation from the foreign country or from a visa office expert showing that adoption is indeed not possible. These foreign countries may not allow adoption, for example, between same-sex couples, or that cross religious lines.

CIC has some discretion in this second scenario. The child could be given a temporary resident permit to enter Canada. Then, from within Canada, CIC can help the intending parents make an application for humanitarian and compassionate permanent residence on behalf of the child. These steps could bring the child citizenship under subsection 5(2) of the Citizenship Act. The bulletin noted a second option that provides CIC descretion, that is, applying under subsection 5(4) of the Citizenship Act for a grant of citizenship. The second option seems far more direct. But, like most government processes, I'm sure there are far more steps involved. 

In all scenarios, parents need to demonstrate intention to parent and evidence of the legal parent/child relationship, this means, the following would have to be submitted:  proof of payment of hospital bills; contractual agreement with the lab; and contractual agreement with the surrogate mother. 

I highly encourage you to check out the bulletin, as I'm only paraphrasing this stuff.

No comments:

Post a Comment